Program comparison
| Requirement | Fannie Mae DUS | Freddie Mac Optigo | CMBS / debt funds | HUD MAP |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Phase I standard | ASTM E1527-21 + Fannie Mae scope | ASTM E1527-21 + Freddie Mac scope | ASTM E1527-21 + lender scope | ASTM E1527-21 + HUD MAP Guide |
| Radon | EP discretion by regional risk | Generally required (multifamily) | Lender discretion | Required per HUD policy |
| Asbestos (ACM) | O&M where suspected; sampling at EP discretion | Damaged suspect ACM sampled | Lender scope | Survey and O&M per HUD MAP Guide |
| Lead-based paint | Pre-1978 multifamily review | Pre-1978 multifamily review | Lender scope | Pre-1978: LBP requirements per HUD |
| Mold / moisture | Visual assessment | Visual assessment | Visual assessment | Visual assessment |
| PCA reserve term | 10 – 15 years | 10 – 15 years | 10 – 15 years | 20 years (PCNA) |
| Seismic | SEL-475 where PGA ≥ 0.15g; > 20% needs retrofit or insurance | SEL-475 where PGA ≥ 0.15g; > 20% needs action | Lender scope; PML/SEL commonly required in seismic zones | Per HUD MAP Guide |
| Immediate repairs escrow | 100% – 150% of Immediate Costs | 100% – 150% | Set by lender | Per HUD critical repair rules |
| Reliance | Lender + Fannie Mae | Lender + Freddie Mac | Lender, successors, trustee, rating agencies | Lender + HUD |
Business Environmental Risks (BERs)
Agency and HUD scopes add Business Environmental Risks that sit outside ASTM E1527-21: asbestos-containing materials, lead-based paint, radon, mold and moisture, and sometimes drinking water. Freddie Mac generally requires radon testing on multifamily and sampling of damaged suspect ACM; Fannie Mae leaves more to the Environmental Professional's judgement, subject to regional risk zones. Ordering the BER work with the Phase I avoids a second site visit.
Capital reserves
Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and CMBS lenders size replacement reserves on a 10 – 15 year schedule from the PCA. HUD MAP loans under Sections 221(d)(4) and 223(f) use a 20-year Project Capital Needs Assessment (PCNA), which takes more field time and a longer reserve table, and is priced higher.
Seismic
Where the 475-year peak ground acceleration is 0.15g or more, agency lenders require an ASTM E2026 / E2557 seismic risk assessment. An SEL-475 above 20% generally means structural retrofit or earthquake insurance (Fannie Mae Forms 4093 / 4099). See ALTA, Zoning & Seismic.
Typical package
| Program | Usual reports |
|---|---|
| Fannie Mae / Freddie Mac | Phase I + BERs, PCA, seismic where required, reliance letters |
| CMBS | Phase I, PCA, ALTA survey, zoning report, seismic in seismic zones, reliance to the trust |
| HUD MAP 223(f) | Phase I to HUD scope, 20-year PCNA, radon, ALTA survey |
